When hackers
break into government servers
to steal your personal data, there's not a darn thing you can do about
it. Protecting those servers isn't your job. What you can do is ensure
that your own devices are protected against data-stealing Trojans and
other sorts of malware by installing antivirus protection. Which
antivirus should you use? We'll help you decide.
Data-stealing Trojans aren't the only type of attacker your antivirus
will block. Despite the name, these utilities protect against a huge
range of malicious programs, including ransomware, spyware, adware,
keyloggers, rootkits, Trojans, actual viruses, and more. Fortunately,
you can also find a huge range of products designed to fight these
malicious programs. PCMag has reviewed over 30 different commercial
antivirus utilities, and that's not even counting
free antivirus tools.
Ten of the premium editions proved effective enough to earn an
excellent four stars or better. Another dozen earned at least three
stars.
Almost all of these products are traditional, full-scale, antivirus
tools, with the ability to scan files for malware on access, on demand,
or on schedule. A couple are outliers, tools meant to enhance the
protection of a traditional antivirus. As for just relying on the
antivirus built into Windows 8.x, that's not such a good idea. According
to both our tests and independent lab tests, Windows Defender won't
keep you safe.
| Name |
Webroot SecureAnywhere AntiVirus (2015)
|
Bitdefender Antivirus Plus 2015
|
Kaspersky Anti-Virus (2015)
|
F-Secure Anti-Virus 2015
|
McAfee AntiVirus Plus 2015
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| Lowest Price |
$19.99
Webroot
|
$39.95
BitDefender
|
$36.60
Amazon
|
$39.99
F-Secure
|
$39.99
Dell
|
| Editor Rating |
|
|
|
|
|
| Type |
Personal, Professional
|
Personal, Professional
|
Business, Personal, Professional
|
Business, Personal, Professional
|
Business, Personal, Professional
|
| OS Compatibility |
Windows Vista, Windows XP, Mac OS, Windows 7, Windows 8
|
Windows Vista, Windows XP, Windows 7, Windows 8
|
Windows Vista, Windows XP, Windows 7, Windows 8
|
Windows Vista, Windows XP, Windows 7, Windows 8
|
Windows Vista, Windows 7, Windows 8
|
| |
Read the Review
|
Read the Review
|
Read the Review
|
Read the Review
|
Read the Review
|
Listen to the Labs
I take the results reported by independent antivirus testing labs very
seriously. The simple fact that a particular vendor's product shows up
in the results is a vote of confidence, of sorts. It means the lab
considered the product significant, and the vendor felt the cost of
testing was worthwhile. Of course, getting good scores in the tests is
also important.
Note, though, that good scores must be obtained honestly, or else
there's no point in testing. Recently, several prominent labs revealed
that one vendor had
deliberately weakened protection
to get a better performance score. PCMag doesn't condone any kind of
chicanery aimed solely at raising test scores. Another vendor
supplied a different version for testing
than the one ordinary users could download. The labs should now be
testing precisely the same version as the one users can download; we'll
see what happens.
I follow six labs that regularly release detailed reports: West Coast Labs, Virus Bulletin, ICSA Labs,
Dennis Technology Labs,
AV-Test Institute, and
AV-Comparatives.
Tests by the first three are based on simple threat-recognition, while
the last three attempt to simulate real-world malware-attack scenarios.
I've devised a
system for aggregating their results to yield a rating from 0 to 5.
I also subject every product to my own hands-on test of malware
blocking, in part to get a feeling for how the product works. Depending
on
how thoroughly the product prevents malware installation, it can earn up to 10 points for malware blocking.
I also test each product using 100 extremely new malware-hosting
URLs, noting what percentage of them it blocked. Products get equal
credit for preventing all access to the malicious URL and for wiping out
the malware during download.
Some products earn absolutely stellar ratings from the independent
labs, yet don't fare as well in my hands-on tests. In such cases, I
defer to the labs, as they bring significantly greater resources to
their testing.
Multi-Layered Antivirus Protection
Antivirus products distinguish themselves by going beyond the basics of
on-demand scanning and real-time protection. Some rate URLs that you
visit or that show up in search results, using a red-yellow-green color
coding system. Some actively block processes on your system from
connecting with known malware-hosting URLs, or with fraudulent
(phishing) pages.
Software has flaws, and sometimes those flaws affect your security.
Prudent users keep Windows and all programs patched, fixing those flaws
as soon as possible. The vulnerability scan offered by some antivirus
products can verify that all necessary patches are present, and even
apply any that are missing.
You expect an antivirus to identify and eliminate bad programs, and
to leave good programs alone. What about unknowns, programs it can't
identify as good or bad? Behavior-based detection can, in theory,
protect you against malware that's so new researchers have never
encountered it. However, this isn't always an unmixed blessing. It's not
uncommon for behavioral detection systems to flag many innocuous
behaviors performed by legitimate programs.
Whitelisting is another approach to the problem of unknown programs. A
whitelist-based security system only allows known good programs to run.
Unknowns are banned. This mode doesn't suit all situations, but it can
be useful. Sandboxing lets unknown programs run, but it isolates them
from full access to your system, so they can't do permanent harm. These
various added layers serve to enhance your protection against malware.
Bonus Features
Firewall protection and spam filtering aren't common antivirus features,
but some of our top products include them as bonus features. In fact,
some of these antivirus products are more feature-packed than certain
products sold as security suites.
Among the other bonus features you'll find are: secure browser for
financial transactions; secure deletion of sensitive files; wiping
traces of computer and browsing history; credit monitoring; virtual
keyboard to foil keyloggers; and more. And of course I've already
mentioned sandboxing, vulnerability scanning, and application
whitelisting.
What's Best?
Which antivirus should you choose? Webroot SecureAnywhere Antivirus
(2015) is the tiniest antivirus around, though its unusual detection
technique doesn't jibe with some lab tests. The independent labs
uniformly heap praise on Kaspersky Anti-Virus (2015). Bitdefender
Antivirus Plus 2015 also gets plenty of love from the labs, and in
AutoPilot mode it stays out of your way. We've named these three
Editors' Choice for commercial antivirus, but they're not the only good
choices. Read the reviews of our top-rated products, then make your own
decision.
FEATURED IN THIS ROUNDUP
Kaspersky Anti-Virus (2015)

$39.95
$36.60 at Amazon
Kaspersky Anti-Virus (2015) made a clean sweep, earning top marks from
all of the independent antivirus test labs. It's a new Editors' Choice
for antivirus protection.
Webroot SecureAnywhere Antivirus (2015)

$39.99
$19.99 at Webroot
Two independent testing labs have given Webroot SecureAnywhere
AntiVirus (2015) their top ratings, and it earned a perfect score in our
hands-on malware blocking test. Add the fact that it's the smallest
antivirus around and you've got a definite Editors' Choice.
Emsisoft Anti-Malware 9.0
$39.95
$49.99 at Amazon
Emsisoft Anti-Malware 9.0 focuses on the central task of fighting all
kinds of malware. Independent lab tests and our own hands-on testing
show that it does quite a good job.
F-Secure Anti-Virus 2015
$39.99
$39.99 at F-Secure
F-Secure Anti-Virus 2015 skips the bells and whistles, instead
focusing solely on antivirus protection. If that's the kind of tool
you're looking for, it can be a very good choice.
McAfee AntiVirus Plus 2015
$49.99
$39.99 at Dell
McAfee AntiVirus Plus 2015 earns a new top score in our malicious URL
blocking test, and it gets good ratings from the independent labs. It
comes with a raft of useful bonus tools, though the bonus firewall
seemed a bit wobbly in our testing.
Panda Antivirus Pro 2015

$39.99
$25.00 at Amazon
Panda Antivirus Pro 2015 has the same excellent antivirus protection
as Panda Free Antivirus 2015, plus a firewall and a handful of other
features. Stick with the free edition for personal use, as the added
features don't justify the cost (except for businesses, which can't use
the free version).
Trend Micro Antivirus+ 2015

$39.95
$25.32 at Amazon
Trend Micro Antivirus+ 2015 has a completely new look, but the
underlying protection hasn't changed. It's especially good at blocking
fraudulent or malicious URLs, and includes spam filtering, firewall
booster, and other bonus features.
VoodooSoft VoodooShield 2.0
$19.99
VoodooSoft's VoodooShield 2.0 supplements your antivirus by blocking
execution of unknown files when you're in a risky state—online, or with a
USB drive plugged in. The free edition does a great job of balancing
protection and flexibility. Give it a try.
AppGuard
$29.95
AppGuard teams up with your existing antivirus to block
never-before-seen zero-day malware. Unknown programs in folders commonly
used by malware just can't launch, and programs that do run can't make
changes to sensitive system areas. It definitely works, but you'll have
to do some finagling to install or update valid programs.
Avast Pro Antivirus 2015
$39.99
Free at Avast
Avast Pro Antivirus 2015 includes an innovative scan for home router
security problems, as well as a hardened browser for financial
transactions and a number of other useful tools. Even so, you'll be
better off selecting one of our Editors' Choice antivirus products
AVG AntiVirus 2015
$39.99
$32.09 at Amazon
Businesses that want to use AVG's antivirus technology can't use the
free version; they must pay for AVG AntiVirus 2015. With the same amount
of cash, however, you could purchase any of our three Editors' Choice
antivirus products.
ESET NOD32 Antivirus 8
$39.99
$39.99 at ESET North America
The independent testing labs give ESET NOD32 Antivirus 8 generally
high ratings, and it did a great job in our malicious URL blocking test.
However, it bombed our hands-on malware blocking test and antiphishing
test.
G Data Antivirus 2015

$39.95
G Data Antivirus 2015 earned decent scores in our hands-on testing,
and rated well with the independent labs that include it in their tests.
However, our Editors' Choice products score even better with the labs.
Anti-Executable 5.2

$45.00
Anti-Executable 5.2 blocks execution of any program that isn't on its
whitelist. It can definitely prevent installation of new malware, as
long as you don't erroneously override its block. However, the average
user may find managing its protection to be a chore.
IObit Advanced SystemCare Ultimate 8
$49.99
If you love tinkering with system utilities, IObit Advanced SystemCare
Ultimate 8 has plenty to offer. However, its actual antivirus
protection can't match that of our Editors' Choice antivirus tools
Kromtech PCKeeper Antivirus

$39.95
Kromtech PCKeeper Antivirus is attractive and easy to use, and it has
chat-based help built right in. However, the chat-based help supplied
misinformation during testing.
Malwarebytes Anti-Malware Premium 2.0
$24.95
Malwarebytes Anti-Malware Premium 2.0 combines the impressive malware
cleanup abilities of the free-for-personal-use Malwarebytes utility with
lackluster real-time protection and malicious URL blocking. Businesses
buying it should consider pairing it with a more effective real-time
antivirus.
Tiranium Premium Security 2014
$25.94
Tiranium Premium Security 2014 did well in my hands-on malware
blocking test, but the independent labs haven't weighed in. The bonus
firewall didn't do anything in our tests, though, and the quality of
other features varied. It's a good first effort.
Valt.X 'Absolute Security for Windows' Special Edition

$89.99
Valt.X 'Absolute Security for Windows' Special Edition rolls your
system back to a safe, malware-free state on every reboot. However, any
malware that does infest your system can run wild until the next reboot,
and external actions like false bank transactions or transmission of
personal data can't be rolled back.